Science Metrics

Nature has a very interesting News Feature on metrics for scientific achievement, titled Metrics: Do metrics matter? The use of scientific metrics is a recurring theme on this blog. I wrote about it most recently in my post Against Measure.The main point of my criticism on science metrics is that they deviate researchers' interests. It is what I refer to as a deviation from primary goals to secondary criteria. Here, the primary goal is good research. The secondary criteria are some measures that for whatever reason are thought to be relevant quantifiers for the primary goal. The problem is that, even if the secondary criteria have initially had some relevance, their implementation inevitably affects researcher's own assessment of what success means and leads them to strive for the secondary criteria rather than the primary goal. With that, the secondary criteria become less and less useful since they are being pursued as an end in itself. Typical example: number of publications. In principle not a completely useless criterion to assess a researcher's productivity. But it becomes increasingly less useful the more tricks scientists pull to increase the number of publications instead of focusing on the quality of their research.Note that for a deviation of interests to happen it is not ...

More on Sciencestage.com

    More on Wikipedia

      Related Videos

      • Dr. Marty D. Matlock - Science-Based Metrics for Sustainable Outcomes in Agriculture
        Dr. Marty D. Matlock - Science-Based Metrics for Sustainable Outcomes in Agriculture Science-Based Metrics for Sustainable Outcomes in Agriculture - Marty D. Matlock, PhD, PE, BCEE, Executive Director, Office for Sustainability, Area Director... From: John Blue Views: 177 1 ratings Time: 37:12 More in Education
      • Steve Coleman And Metrics - Science(1994)
        Steve Coleman And Metrics - Science(1994) EP(1994) hip hop jazz. From: liam stoker Views: 415 4 ratings Time: 07:30 More in Music
      • Making Science Metrics More Scientific by Julia Lane
        Making Science Metrics More Scientific by Julia Lane The Impact Agenda, Seminar 4: Good management, government and science For more methods resources see: http://www.methods.manchester.ac.uk. From: methods@manchester Views: 21 0 ratings Time: 57:24 More in Education
      • Steve Coleman And Metrics - Science
        Steve Coleman And Metrics - Science 1994. From: Schmoovnyz Views: 3768 23 ratings Time: 07:31 More in Music
      • NARA 2013 Annual Meeting: Feedstock Sustainability
        NARA 2013 Annual Meeting: Feedstock Sustainability Greg Johnson, NARA Team Leader of Systems Metrics Sustainable Production Team, provides overview of feedstock sustainability studies. From: nararenewables Views: 11 0 ratings Time: 22:27 More in Science & Technology
      • RightBio Metrics - Corporate Video
        RightBio Metrics - Corporate Video RightBio Metrics is the leading provider of fluid measurement technologies to healthcare. Our fluid measurement solutions challenge existing clinical and hea... From: RightBio Metrics Views: 41 0 ratings Time: 06:19 More in Science & Technology
      • Introduction to Science WoRx
        Introduction to Science WoRx Presentation by Adam Miller at the 2012 CSG National Leadership Conference in La Quinta, California. Policymakers, parents and stakeholders are demanding imp... From: CSGovts Views: 13 0 ratings Time: 13:41 More in Nonprofits & Activism
      • soil science project 2 - by Wideo.co
        soil science project 2 - by Wideo.co This online video was created and exported from http://www.wideo.co ********************... From: saxophone520 Views: 1 0 ratings Time: 03:34 More in People & Blogs
      • Is advertising without measurement redundant?
        Is advertising without measurement redundant? Andrew Hall of Hero discusses why he believes that ad campaigns without measurability are redundant. "Clients nowadays require far more measurement on their ... From: Adlip Channel Views: 14 0 ratings Time: 04:31 More in People & Blogs
      • SpotOn London 2012: Can we work together to better evaluate online engagement?
        SpotOn London 2012: Can we work together to better evaluate online engagement? Online science engagement gives us lots of data. But how do we move from a plethora of abstract metrics to more meaningful indicators of success? We could st... From: SpotOnLondonOutreach Views: 0 0 ratings Time: 59:17 More in Science & Technology
      • "Elsevier, publishing, discover and mesure science", David Miño
        "Elsevier, publishing, discover and mesure science", David Miño Comunicação de David Miño no Painel Trends in Publishing Science na Conferência "Comunicar Ciência: A Publicação Científica e os Seus Públicos", realizada n... From: Adriano Cerqueira Views: 30 0 ratings Time: 37:03 More in Science & Technology
      • Science Centre Slime Making Workshop For 25 Hours Of Science
        Science Centre Slime Making Workshop For 25 Hours Of Science July 5, 2014 until 3pm! From: Saskatchewan Science Centre Views: 45 1 ratings Time: 00:40 More in Education
      • Occupy Wall Street Help - Market Science
        Occupy Wall Street Help - Market Science The Occupy Wall Street movement is leaderless movement that few know what it is really about. They hate the 1% but past that it is anyone's guess. David Meer... From: TPNDigitalMarketing Views: 70 0 ratings Time: 03:43 More in News & Politics
      • iMedia Brand Summit 2013: Case Study: The Science Behind the Art of Kraft's Delicious Content
        iMedia Brand Summit 2013: Case Study: The Science Behind the Art of Kraft's Delicious Content Dana Shank makes her case study presentation at the 2013 iMedia Brand Summit. From: iMedia Connection Views: 19 1 ratings Time: 15:30 More in Science & Technology
      • Telstra Business case study - Aust. Inst. of Marine Science Monitoring the health of our eco-system
        Telstra Business case study - Aust. Inst. of Marine Science Monitoring the health of our eco-system From: telstrabusinessvideo Views: 51 0 ratings Time: 02:07 More in Science & Technology
      • What is Science?
        What is Science? "What is Science?" It's a basic question, but it's not always easy to define, and many people don't really understand what science is. I clear it up in this ... From: Matt Parker Views: 37 1 ratings Time: 03:19 More in Science & Technology
      • Progress Software Jan 2005 Kickoff Preso NextStage CRO Joseph Carrabis Pt 3 - NextStage's Difference
        Progress Software Jan 2005 Kickoff Preso NextStage CRO Joseph Carrabis Pt 3 - NextStage's Difference RichPersonae, Consumer Response, Real Time Behaviors, The Ten Must Marketing Messages, Simple Solutions - Easy Changes - Major Benefits, Visitor Action Metri... From: NextStageEvolution1 Views: 6 0 ratings Time: 15:01 More in Education
      • Service Oriented Science
        Service Oriented Science A talk given at the Unilever Centre, Cambridge as part of a symposium on Semantic Physical Science, in January 2012. Touches on the Research Works Act and wa... From: Cameron Neylon Views: 9 0 ratings Time: 18:48 More in Science & Technology
      • DIDSON - Staff Favorite - Fish digging
        DIDSON - Staff Favorite - Fish digging Fish digging during the 2012-2013 season. From: SFNPS Science and Learning Views: 38 0 ratings Time: 00:18 More in Science & Technology
      • We collaborate with science research
        We collaborate with science research Interview with Dr P. Anandan, MD, MSR India, September 19, 2008, 1 pm. From: Murali D Views: 42 0 ratings Time: 00:47 More in People & Blogs
      • The Science of Listening - BGF 2012
        The Science of Listening - BGF 2012 The Science of Listening Mark Robinson (Games Analytics) Check out the new BGF: http://bgf2013.de. From: BGFCon Views: 12 0 ratings Time: 21:42 More in Science & Technology
      • Prof Ray Harris, College University London, UK - ICSU and the Challenges of Big Data in Science
        Prof Ray Harris, College University London, UK - ICSU and the Challenges of Big Data in Science Presentation Link: http://asia.elsevier.com/asiamailings/ANZ/Big%20DataE-ScienceandScience%20Policy/Day%201/Ray%20Harris_College%20University%20London_UK.pdf. From: ResearchTrends Elsevier Views: 47 0 ratings Time: 23:49 More in Science & Technology
      • Dr. Clifford on Standards for Success
        Dr. Clifford on Standards for Success Our management approach is to constantly be raising the bar on all metrics. We have to meet your institution where you are and we use peer group benchmarks t... From: SignificantSystems.org Views: 10 0 ratings Time: 00:46 More in Education
      • Panel: What Has Social Done for Me Lately? Measuring Performance in the Age of ROI
        Panel: What Has Social Done for Me Lately? Measuring Performance in the Age of ROI Ultimately, every brand manager in social media has to face the CMO -- and often, the CFO -- to prove that all of those "Likes", followers and pins have actu... From: MediaPost Views: 38 0 ratings Time: 44:47 More in People & Blogs
      • Sentrx interview at Partnerships For Clinical Trials 2010
        Sentrx interview at Partnerships For Clinical Trials 2010 From: Life Science Leader Views: 24 0 ratings Time: 02:06 More in Science & Technology

      More on answers.yahoo.com

      More on Pubmed

        More on Answers.com